Where To Eat in Edinburgh in 2024

By Ellie Smith

4 months ago

Stuart Ralston's food recommendations for the vibrant Scottish capital


Heading to Edinburgh for the Fringe and wondering where to eat? You’ll be spoilt for choice: the city’s food scene is thriving, with a healthy mixture of Michelin-starred restaurants, upmarket dining rooms and trendy cafés. Here Stuart Ralston, chef and owner of Aizle plus new restaurant Lyla, shares his favourite culinary spots, plus some top picks from the C&TH team.

Stuart Ralston’s culinary career has taken him through some of the best kitchens in the UK, the US and the Caribbean, cooking for stars of the TV, film, music and fashion industries. He opened Aizle with his wife Krystal in 2014, where it made its mark as one of Edinburgh’s best loved eateries. There’s no traditional menu on display: instead guests are privy only to a list of ingredients which are used in the six-course tasting menu, dictated wholly by what is local and in season. Stuart’s menus are influenced by classical French styles and Asian cuisine, drawing inspiration from the flavours of Japan.

Aizle

Stuart also owns a restaurant in the city centre: Noto, a New York-inspired restaurant named after Stuart’s late friend Bob Noto, who took Stuart under his wing when he first arrived in the Big Apple. Noto offers an international repertoire of small and large dishes, with a focus on Asian and American cuisine – the menu features pork bao buns, but also fried buttermilk chicken with waffles.

Dining tables at Lyla, a restaurant in Edinburgh

This month, he has opened another restaurant called Lyla. Set in a Georgian townhouse, the intimate space will feel akin to having dinner in someone’s home, with a 10-course tasting menu focusing on seafood. Dishes will be guided by the ingredients available, but you can expect the likes of caviar with wild bream and sea buckthorn, and Isle of Skye langoustine with bonito emulsion.

Here, Stuart gives us his recommendations for the best restaurants in Edinburgh.

Stuart’s Pick: The Best Places to Eat in Edinburgh

‘Edinburgh’s dining scene is in a good place, with plenty of choice and plenty of quality independent food and drink businesses, from Michelin stars to casual bistros. I have operated Aizle now for over five years and our business has grown and grown in that time, despite not being in the most central location, which tells me that people will travel a little for quality.

‘I think the future seems a little uncertain: rising rents, business rates and a constant influx of corporations makes being competitive very hard without larger investment so I have huge respect for the independents still battling it out. All in all I feel lucky to live and work as part of Edinburgh’s scene and would like to continue to grow within the city and see where it takes me next.’

Stuart Ralston

Yamato

I was always a big fan of Kanpai on Grindlay St, but their sister restaurant Yamato is my new go-to place. I love Japanese cuisine anyway but they always have Toro Tuna belly which I love. yamatosushiedinburgh.co.uk

Eddie’s Seafood Market & Fishmongers

Eddie’s Seafood Market is a local legend which has been there for years – my wife Krystal shops there often for our little boy Sonny, they have amazing fish. It’s a true neighbourhood business in the sense that its in a great location for families, has great prices and the service is second to none. eddiesseafood.co.uk

Company Bakery

A new venture from a few local independents including Hollie Love Reid from Lovecrumbs, Company Bakery mill their own flour and have a great ethos. I really love their sourdough, we’ve used it for off-site events before. companybakery.com

IJ Mellis Cheesemonger

I have used Mellis for cheese for as long as I can remember. They always give out samples and introduce you to new cheeses, charcuterie and condiments – and what’s better than cheese and bread? They’re my favourite snacks to go with a glass of great wine with friends. mellischeese.net

Mary’s Milk Bar

My son’s favourite treat is ice cream and Mary’s Milk Bar does great gelato; it’s a nice way to spend a sunny day with my boy when he has been well behaved. My favourite flavour is salted caramel, but Sonny is more of a traditionalist chocolate gelato man. marysmilkbar.com

Aizle, Edinburgh

Our Top Picks: Best Edinburgh Restaurants

Eleanore

Eleanore's pork chops

Roberta Hall-McCarron – the chef brains behind the Little Chartroom, which you might remember from its lockdown jaunt into beachside dining – offers up a delightful tiny dining space with Eleanore. The restaurant, now in its third year, sits off of Albert Place, in Leith. The menu promises fine-dining that’s still strikingly laid-back – despite having achieved numerous accolades (Edinburgh Restaurant awards; Square meal) and landing in the Michelin Guide.

Particularly exciting is the lunchtime tasting menu, because this is a reasonably priced foray into brilliant multi-course dining. Think covered-in-truffle beef croustades to start, accompanied by garlicky kimchi and saltier than the sea capers, followed up by a mid-menu bread course doused in herby butter, and showcasing the best of wild Scottish game when you finally reach the main courses. In our visit, we tried a venison with a pickled elderberry accompaniment and sauce so that it was impossible to resist dipping fingers into before plates were cleared. Every dish in this space feels like a discovery, and as there are so few covers in the dining room, you’ll feel as though you’re sat in a pretty bar more than an eaterie. Our only warning? Avoid plotting this one in for a workday – you’ll want to pick over your food for far more than an hour. eleanore.uk

Tipo

Vodka pasta

Stuart Ralston might blush, given we’ve spotlighted his favourite restaurants in this article already, but we’d be loath to leave you without the recommendation of his italian-inspired eaterie, Tipo. This is a little hole in the wall moments from Queen Street, which sports perfect window seats for watching the world go by as you dig into a lay of small plates. 

As for the actual food, these will arrive in a steady stream as and when they’re ready – and ready yourself for the sheer range Ralston’s menus are capable of. Unlike his very refined menu at Lyla, Tipo has a nostalgia factor to it. Zeppole, for instance, arrives with an actual mountain of pecorino and crumbles upon a bite – these are less the traditional ball of savoury doughnut so much as a tangle of carby limb that is dusted with chilli – and ultimately tastes a bit like a grown-up wotsit. Even more like a children’s birthday party (given a few years and a graduation ceremony) is the vodka pasta – this is a ravioli in a sauce that makes you think of heinz from when you were a kid. The food here is feel-good; Tipo is one to visit if you want to share a smile with loved ones over a brilliant meal. tipoedinburgh.co.uk

Le Petit Beefbar

Image: Ben Anders

In July 2023 Edinburgh became the latest destination to receive the blessing of Riccardo Giraudi to open a new outpost of his fabled Monte Carlo-born Le Petit Beefbar chain. Located in the InterContinental Edinburgh The George, on George Street, right in the humming city centre, the entrance is also directly from the street so it certainly doesn’t feel like you’re in a hotel restaurant. Far from it. It’s more glamorous brasserie, with its white walls, lofty ceilings, brass light fittings and lots of towering greenery.

Beef, of course, is the star here – the provenance of its cuts is impeccable, so from the skirt to the 34-day dry aged T-bone; from the baguette to the Black Angus ribeye – juicy, succulent, taste-dripping dishes await. But you can dodge the cow too. The salads are magnificent. And the starters are generally big enough for two, so don’t over order.

Dishes from £9. beefbar.com

The Witchery

Celebrating over 30 years at the kitchen helm, The Witchery’s Head Chef Dougal Roberts has launched a special summer menu drawing on British and European cooking, showcasing the very best of local Scottish produce from the land and sea. For lunch, try the likes of Soupe au Pistou with summer vegetables, haricot beans and home-made pesto, or Smoked ‘Eddie’s Cure’ Salmon with warmed blinis, lemon jam and crème freche. Come dinner time, the a la carte pays homage to the local area, with East Lothian Lobster, Skye Langoustines and Cumbrae oysters, Scallops hand-dived in the icy waters off Orkney, served with langoustine bisque and black garlic. Don’t miss dessert: from the Summer Trifle with Perthshire strawberries and white chocolate to the Pink Lady Tart Tarin with English custard and ice cream, there’s a perfect sweet treat for everyone. thewitchery.com

Ting Thai Caravan

Beginning as as a small pop-up with just four dishes, Ting Thai Caravan is now a hugely popular Thai restaurant, with interesting, hearty dishes for great prices. Just down the road you’ll find its younger sibling, Saboteur  – a cool Vietnamese street food restaurant serving up irresistible bao buns to a young crowd. tingthai-caravan.com

The Gardener’s Cottage

Gardener's Cottage

Another Edinburgh gem is The Gardener’s Cottage, a magical space housed in – you guessed it – a former single-storey gardener’s cottage. Found at the foot of Calton Hill, the restaurant is made up of two small dining rooms with three communal tables. The cottage itself dates all the way back to the 1800s, and stood for many years as the home to the gardener of Edinburgh’s Royal Terrace Gardens. When the cottage became derelict in 2012, chef duo Ed Murray and Dale Mailley bagged the rights to transform it into a restaurant, complete with a resident gardener, Charlie, who grows fruit, vegetables and herbs in the front garden. Food is seasonal – naturally – with no printed menu and dishes reflecting the best ingredients available that day. Dale also heads up The Lookout, which opened in 2019 after much anticipation. Perched at the top of Calton Hill, it’s a smart spot boasting floor-to-ceiling views of the city, with a refined menu to match. thegardenerscottage.co

Hula Juice Bar & Gallery

Get your brunch fix at Hula Juice Bar in Grassmarket, which serves up smoothie bowls, sourdough sandwiches and colourful salads to Edinburgh’s health foodies. hula.co.uk

Twelve Triangles

Twelve Triangles

Popular Edinburgh bakery Twelve Triangles has four branches across Edinburgh, all of which stock a mouth-watering selection of breads, pastries and doughnuts. Run by former costume designer Rachel Morgan and baker Emily Cuddeford, everything is handmade daily, using local, seasonal and organic ingredients where possible, including flour milled locally by Mungoswells Millers in East Lothian. Don’t miss the brownies. twelvetriangles.co.uk

Fhior

Scott Smith fans were left saddened by the closure of his debut restaurant, Norn – but luckily they didn’t have to wait long to taste his cooking again. His second venture, Fhior, opened its doors on Broughton Street in summer 2019, with a focus on honesty (‘Fhior’ translates as true in Gaelic): really good quality modern Scottish cuisine and a relaxed atmosphere. fhior.com

Timberyard

Timberyard, Edinburgh

A friendly, family-run restaurant found on Lady Lawson Street, Timberyard is a must-visit in Edinburgh. It offers a new Nordic approach to Scottish food, with set menus ranging from four to six courses, with pescatarian and vegetarian options available. Dishes include the likes of ox tartare, glazed hake and sea kale, barbecued leek with potato and smoked curd, and a delicious carrot and walnut cake. timberyard.co

The Scran & Scallie

A walk through Stockbridge (start all the way in Dean Village and wend your way along the river) will take you to the doorstep of The Scran & Scallie, and rest assured, they will take it from there. Characterful, knowledgable and witty restaurant staff will make you feel right at home, and the interiors help to this effect. A cosy, brick fire place, fluffy chair throw here and there, plus whimsical wall paper are all homey, stylish and Scottish. Now is the time to go for pub classics: The Scran & Scallie steak pie is the house favourite. scranandscallie.com

Archipelago Bakery

A small, off-the-tourist-track bakery in Edinburgh’s new town, Archipelago Bakery serves up fresh bread, salads and brownies, all made by friendly founder Caroline. The outdoor tables are perfect for sunny brunches and lunches. archipelagobakery.com

The Little Chartroom

The Little Chartroom

Isabel McCabe

Opened in 2020 by husband-wife duo Roberta Hall-McCarron (formerly Castle Terrace and The Kitchin) and Shaun McCarron, The Little Chartroom is a lovely neighbourhood restaurant located in the up-and-coming area of Leith. Interiors are cosy, food is creative and flavoursome, and it’s perfectly located for Fringe events at the top of Edinburgh’s Leith Walk. thelittlechartroom.com